The Holiday Season in New York City (Almost): Our 3-Day Itinerary

Spending the holiday season in New York City has been a dream for awhile and last year we finally got to do it. Well, sort of). We spent three days in the city during the third week in November so not all of the holiday season activities were in full swing. Also, with limited time there were plenty of things we didn’t get to do. Regardless, this plan is a great starter for setting your NYC holiday itinerary.

Our 3-Day Itinerary for the Holiday Season in New York City

Our trip to NYC really was planned around our tickets to see Tom Felton starring in the Cursed Child on Broadway. But we also had one other must do: the Rockettes Christmas Spectacular. Both are included in the itinerary, but everything we did is very customizable depending on what interests you. Also, if you go a little later in the year (even just one week), you’ll have more Christmas season options; we’ve included some of those within and at the end of this article.

Day 1: Afternoon Arrival in NYC

We arrived from Denver to New York City around 3:30 pm on a Tuesday in mid-November. After checking into our hotel in Times Square, we took the train to Chelsea for a before-dinner drink. We happened upon NBetween in the Chelsea Market. This cocktail bar plays all its music on vinyl and had some of the best – and creative – cocktails we’ve had in awhile. The drink on the right side of the photo below is the N°Between Martini and it has heirloom tomato as one of the ingredients. It was SO GOOD. I had to limit myself since we had a whole evening ahead, ha!

For dinner, WC made a reservation at the Old Homestead, an NYC steakhouse that dates back to 1868. He had been there on a bachelor party years before. It had some Christmas decor and felt cozy in a booth near the back of the restaurant. We shared the porterhouse for two but the hard part was choosing between all the side options. We landed on mushroom caps, creamed spinach, and a truffle butter baked potato. The wine menu is also a tough choice; it’s a huge list!

After dinner, we wanted a nightcap and found Bathtub Gin, a speakeasy that’s been open since 2011. We were able to get a spot at the bar but I’d recommend a reservation, especially if you’re planning to go during a live burlesque performance or live music.

Day 2: Rockettes & Christmas Bar

The Rockettes Christmas Spectacular has been a longtime dream of mine and it definitely surpassed my expectations. We booked the 2:00 pm show and arrived early so we could spend time in the lobby and check out the merch. It happened to be the 100th anniversary of the Rockettes so there was some additional decor celebrating the milestone.

During the holiday season in New York City, the Christmas bars are not to be missed! We only had time to fit one in and we chose Papillon which transforms into a Christmas wonderland at the end of November. (Rolf’s is another popular “Christmas bar” but it keeps the decor up all year round.)

During our visit the decor had just started going up so it wasn’t fully decked out yet but there was still plenty to get us in the spirit.

Friends of ours from Florida, Mark and Maria, also happened to be in New York City the same week and we were excited they could join us at Papillon. A few cocktails later we even had dinner plans that night to celebrate Mark’s birthday, but we’ll get to that spot in a bit!

After Papillon we headed back to our hotel to change into more comfortable clothes. From there we walked from Times Square toward our dinner spot passing through Herald Square along the way. Macy’s Herald Square is an NYC Christmas staple and it was decorated beautifully as expected.

On the topic of Macy’s, “Santaland” is an iconic Christmas spot. It doesn’t open until the end of November but be sure to keep an eye on the website if you’re planning to visit. Reservations are required and open one week in advance.

For Mark’s birthday dinner he chose Skirt Steak, a restaurant that specializes in…. you guessed it, prime skirt steak! The menu is very simple: skirt steak cooked to your preferred temp, endless fries, and salad. You can add on sides which vary day by day. And there’s a dessert trolley with lots of options if you save room.

After dinner wrapped, WC and I headed back to Times Square with the thought of popping by the Lyric Theatre to see if people were lined up for post-Cursed Child autographs. The line along the fence was pretty full, but there were a few remaining front row spots so we sidled up to wait for the show to end. We had no idea whether the cast would come out, but I had seen a video online showing Tom Felton signing autographs after the show. Well, we got SO lucky, not only did we get his autograph but we also got a photo. I shared about the experience and tips for you to do the same in this post.

Day 3: Afternoon Tea, Central Park, Holiday Market, Harry Potter

If you know us, you know we love afternoon tea! I booked a reservation at Lillie’s Victorian Establishment, which is known for its holiday decor. Unfortunately we were a week too early for the decor changeover which takes place the last week in November. Of note: the Union Square location switches to Christmas decor one week earlier. Regardless, the restaurant is very charming with its victorian decor. The afternoon tea itself I will say isn’t our favorite we’ve had. It didn’t feel as much like a “tea” place and more of a restaurant. This may be because we were the only people doing tea at the time. Still, it was a fun way to start the day. Plus, hot tea will warm you up when it’s cold outside!

After tea, we headed to Central Park to enjoy the fall colors on the trees. The park is so beautiful in November with the mix of green, yellow, orange, and red.

Next we headed over to the Bryant Park holiday market and wandered through the stalls. While there is some decor and Christmas lights on the stalls, it felt a bit like it could have been a market anytime of the year to us. Once you get to the other side with the ice skating rink, it feels a little more Christmas-y.

After browsing, we ducked into the Lodge Bar and found a seat at the counter for a cocktail and a mulled wine. The tent is in the middle of the market and is decorated like a ski chalet. It’s a great way to warm up after wandering the stalls or ice skating.

All warmed up, we headed back to the hotel to change and get ready for the evening and Cursed Child play. Before the show, we stopped The Dickens bar for a cocktail. The martinis were festive and delicious!

Finally it was time for the show! This actually wasn’t our first time seeing Cursed Child; we initially saw it in London on our honeymoon when it debuted on the West End. This was, of course, our first time seeing it with one of the cast members from the original movie series! Tom Felton was fabulous and could barely get his first lines out with all the applause from the audience.

Day 4: Morning in the City, Afternoon Departure

We had a great time enjoying the holiday season in NYC! But after a busy three days, all we did on our final morning was get a bagel on the way to the airport.

And that’s a wrap on our holiday trip to the Big Apple. Our only piece of advice would be to go at least one week later in the season if you want to ensure ALL the Christmas activities are in full swing. But if earlier in November works best for you, you’ll still find plenty of holiday magic.

Other Activities for the Holiday Season in New York City (Not Mentioned Previously):

There are some holiday activities we didn’t have time for. Also, it was early in the holiday season so some activities weren’t going yet (and some we just didn’t have time for!) so you might want to add these to your itinerary:

  • Rockefeller Center Christmas Tree Lighting (usually first week in December)
  • Holiday window display at Bergdorf Goodman and Sak’s Fifth Avenue (these were debuting the weekend after we left)
  • Christmas decor and afternoon tea at The Plaza (hotel from Home Alone: Lost in New York)
  • Ice skating at Rockefeller, Central Park
  • Holiday markets at Times Square, Union Square
  • Dyker Heights neighborhood Christmas decor
  • North Pole Express holiday lights tour
  • Other holiday shows like the Nutcracker Ballet or A Christmas Carol
  • Holiday Train Show at New York Botanical Garden
  • Holiday Lights at Bronx Zoo

Enjoy our blog post? Pin it to share with others!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *